Puppy toss Options

[Mommy]

I will never understand the primitive mind who still believes animals are somehow meaningless, feelingless creatures. Kind of like how black people were thought of at one time.

you're a moron and you need to read what The Chicken wrote better. He said he doesn't condone the action, but it is just an animal. Where you were able to draw the comparison to blacks, I will never understand. Shut up

[Billy]

you're a moron and you need to read what The Chicken wrote better. He said he doesn't condone the action, but it is just an animal. Where you were able to draw the comparison to blacks, I will never understand. Shut up

You're calling me a moron?

Take a look at your life and rethink that.

Thanks.

[Dogmeat]

you cannot possibly be defending this?

Absolutley not, and like I said, I'd love to personally torture the guys nuts and laugh at what a pussy he is.

I will never understand the primitive mind who still believes animals are somehow meaningless, feelingless creatures. Kind of like how black people were thought of at one time.

yeah, that's pretty much my thoughts on it as well ...

[Mommy]

You're calling me a moron?

Take a look at your life and rethink that.

Thanks.

You're the equating a DOG to a black person.... how degrading is that??!?!? Completely irrelevant and absoulely moronic.

And I can't ever remember for the life of me if you're Billy or Charlie. Either way, I have absolutely no reason to have an ounce of respect for you. Additionally, I don't see how me calling you a moron for above stated reason constitutes you bringing in my personal life (which I have no regrets about and am quite proud of how things have turned out).

[Dogmeat]

You're the equating a DOG to a black person.... how degrading is that??!?!? Completely irrelevant and absoulely moronic.

And I can't ever remember for the life of me if you're Billy or Charlie. Either way, I have absolutely no reason to have an ounce of respect for you. Additionally, I don't see how me calling you a moron for above stated reason constitutes you bringing in my personal life (which I have no regrets about and am quite proud of how things have turned out).

He wasn't equating a dog to a black person....He was pointing out that white folk in the south and other places 100 years ago did.

[Mommy]

I will never understand the primitive mind who still believes animals are somehow meaningless, feelingless creatures. Kind of like how black people were thought of at one time.

That's relating this situation to the situation surrounding civil rights.... Sorry, that's equating the two

[Hartmann]

So comes the philosophical question. I think this guy deserves to be punished for doing it but I've gotta ask this question anyway.

You are driving down the road, there's a dog that you can avoid only by swerving into oncoming traffic and killing/severely injuring the driving in an oncoming car. If you don't swerve, you kill the dog.

What do you do?

[impala454]

I will never understand the primitive mind who still believes animals are somehow meaningless, feelingless creatures.

Ever had a burger? Hope you've never swatted any flies or spiders. Or gone fishing. Or are only the cute puppies the meaningful, feeling creatures?

Kind of like how black people were thought of at one time.

Well the (as you call it) primitive minds didn't know what we do now did they? Don't sit on your high horse and act like if you'd have been born and raised in those times that you'd have thought any differently.

And this still really has nothing to do with the topic at hand. Animal's "rights" are clearly defined by our laws. Just as black people's rights were clearly defined back then as well. This guy broke the law and will probably receive punishment when they find out who it was (providing the vid is real).

[impala454]

So comes the philosophical question. I think this guy deserves to be punished for doing it but I've gotta ask this question anyway.

You are driving down the road, there's a dog that you can avoid only by swerving into oncoming traffic and killing/severely injuring the driving in an oncoming car. If you don't swerve, you kill the dog.

What do you do?

That doesn't really have anything to do with this either... it's not like the guy had to choose between throwing the puppy and saving a human life. I think the answer to your hypothetical is obvious...

[Hartmann]

That doesn't really have anything to do with this either... it's not like the guy had to choose between throwing the puppy and saving a human life. I think the answer to your hypothetical is obvious...

It is but it is in regards to holding human life in higher regard than animal life. Clearly the guy in the video has no value on animal life but most people hold human life higher.

[impala454]

Right and to expand on that, there are people on the extreme flip side of that, who friggin sign their Christmas cards w/their f'n pet's name, have birthdays & funerals and crap, etc.

[FORSAKENR320]

Either way... its a dog... not like they threw a baby. Its horrible, but that wouldn't even get you a prison sentence in the United States.

actually......

Assault Domestic (beating your wife) $1000 bond

Animal Cruelty (beating a dog) $5000 bond

[Billy]

So comes the philosophical question. I think this guy deserves to be punished for doing it but I've gotta ask this question anyway.

You are driving down the road, there's a dog that you can avoid only by swerving into oncoming traffic and killing/severely injuring the driving in an oncoming car. If you don't swerve, you kill the dog.

What do you do?

I would hit the dog.

If you replaced "dog" with "person" I would still hit the person. Ultimately, it wouldn't matter what species walked into the road, I would hit whatever walked into the road.

[Billy]

You're the equating a DOG to a black person.... how degrading is that??!?!? Completely irrelevant and absoulely moronic.

And I can't ever remember for the life of me if you're Billy or Charlie. Either way, I have absolutely no reason to have an ounce of respect for you. Additionally, I don't see how me calling you a moron for above stated reason constitutes you bringing in my personal life (which I have no regrets about and am quite proud of how things have turned out).

So in summary, you're still retarded. Great.

[Billy]

Ever had a burger? Hope you've never swatted any flies or spiders. Or gone fishing. Or are only the cute puppies the meaningful, feeling creatures?
Well the (as you call it) primitive minds didn't know what we do now did they? Don't sit on your high horse and act like if you'd have been born and raised in those times that you'd have thought any differently.

And this still really has nothing to do with the topic at hand. Animal's "rights" are clearly defined by our laws. Just as black people's rights were clearly defined back then as well. This guy broke the law and will probably receive punishment when they find out who it was (providing the vid is real).

There is a difference between eating a cow, and treating it as if it were trash we can just destroy and torture because it entertains us.

As far as flies or spiders go, I typically try to get them outside without killing them. Doesn't always work out, especially with insects that can cause harm (like black widows).

And last note, please think about this statement: "Don't sit on your high horse and act like if you'd have been born and raised in those times that you'd have thought any differently. "

Obviously, I'm the one thinking "differently" now, so why wouldn't I be the one that would think "differently" then? I see an injustice, and I voice my opinion.

I think I'll stay on my high horse. It's better for nature.